As noted by Florian Weimer, current Linux posix_spawn implementation
can trigger an assert if the auxiliary process is terminated before
actually setting the err member:
340 /* Child must set args.err to something non-negative - we rely on
341 the parent and child sharing VM. */
342 args.err = -1;
[...]
362 new_pid = CLONE (__spawni_child, STACK (stack, stack_size), stack_size,
363 CLONE_VM | CLONE_VFORK | SIGCHLD, &args);
364
365 if (new_pid > 0)
366 {
367 ec = args.err;
368 assert (ec >= 0);
Another possible issue is killing the child between setting the err and
actually calling execve. In this case the process will not ran, but
posix_spawn also will not report any error:
269
270 args->err = 0;
271 args->exec (args->file, args->argv, args->envp);
As suggested by Andreas Schwab, this patch removes the faulty assert
and also handles any signal that happens before fork and execve as the
spawn was successful (and thus relaying the handling to the caller to
figure this out). Different than Florian, I can not see why using
atomics to set err would help here, essentially the code runs
sequentially (due CLONE_VFORK) and I think it would not be legal the
compiler evaluate ec without checking for new_pid result (thus there
is no need to compiler barrier).
Summarizing the possible scenarios on posix_spawn execution, we
have:
1. For default case with a success execution, args.err will be 0, pid
will not be collected and it will be reported to caller.
2. For default failure case, args.err will be positive and the it will
be collected by the waitpid. An error will be reported to the
caller.
3. For the unlikely case where the process was terminated and not
collected by a caller signal handler, it will be reported as succeful
execution and not be collected by posix_spawn (since args.err will
be 0). The caller will need to actually handle this case.
4. For the unlikely case where the process was terminated and collected
by caller we have 3 other possible scenarios:
4.1. The auxiliary process was terminated with args.err equal to 0:
it will handled as 1. (so it does not matter if we hit the pid
reuse race since we won't possible collect an unexpected
process).
4.2. The auxiliary process was terminated after execve (due a failure
in calling it) and before setting args.err to -1: it will also
be handle as 1. but with the issue of not be able to report the
caller a possible execve failures.
4.3. The auxiliary process was terminated after args.err is set to -1:
this is the case where it will be possible to hit the pid reuse
case where we will need to collected the auxiliary pid but we
can not be sure if it will be expected one. I think for this
case we need to actually change waitpid to use WNOHANG to avoid
hanging indefinitely on the call and report an error to caller
since we can't differentiate between a default failure as 2.
and a possible pid reuse race issue.
Checked on x86_64-linux-gnu.
* sysdeps/unix/sysv/linux/spawni.c (__spawnix): Handle the case where
the auxiliary process is terminated by a signal before calling _exit
or execve.
This directory contains the sources of the GNU C Library.
See the file "version.h" for what release version you have.
The GNU C Library is the standard system C library for all GNU systems,
and is an important part of what makes up a GNU system. It provides the
system API for all programs written in C and C-compatible languages such
as C++ and Objective C; the runtime facilities of other programming
languages use the C library to access the underlying operating system.
In GNU/Linux systems, the C library works with the Linux kernel to
implement the operating system behavior seen by user applications.
In GNU/Hurd systems, it works with a microkernel and Hurd servers.
The GNU C Library implements much of the POSIX.1 functionality in the
GNU/Hurd system, using configurations i[4567]86-*-gnu. The current
GNU/Hurd support requires out-of-tree patches that will eventually be
incorporated into an official GNU C Library release.
When working with Linux kernels, this version of the GNU C Library
requires Linux kernel version 3.2 or later.
Also note that the shared version of the libgcc_s library must be
installed for the pthread library to work correctly.
The GNU C Library supports these configurations for using Linux kernels:
aarch64*-*-linux-gnu
alpha*-*-linux-gnu
arm-*-linux-gnueabi
hppa-*-linux-gnu Not currently functional without patches.
i[4567]86-*-linux-gnu
x86_64-*-linux-gnu Can build either x86_64 or x32
ia64-*-linux-gnu
m68k-*-linux-gnu
microblaze*-*-linux-gnu
mips-*-linux-gnu
mips64-*-linux-gnu
powerpc-*-linux-gnu Hardware or software floating point, BE only.
powerpc64*-*-linux-gnu Big-endian and little-endian.
s390-*-linux-gnu
s390x-*-linux-gnu
sh[34]-*-linux-gnu
sparc*-*-linux-gnu
sparc64*-*-linux-gnu
tilegx-*-linux-gnu
tilepro-*-linux-gnu
If you are interested in doing a port, please contact the glibc
maintainers; see http://www.gnu.org/software/libc/ for more
information.
See the file INSTALL to find out how to configure, build, and install
the GNU C Library. You might also consider reading the WWW pages for
the C library at http://www.gnu.org/software/libc/.
The GNU C Library is (almost) completely documented by the Texinfo manual
found in the `manual/' subdirectory. The manual is still being updated
and contains some known errors and omissions; we regret that we do not
have the resources to work on the manual as much as we would like. For
corrections to the manual, please file a bug in the `manual' component,
following the bug-reporting instructions below. Please be sure to check
the manual in the current development sources to see if your problem has
already been corrected.
Please see http://www.gnu.org/software/libc/bugs.html for bug reporting
information. We are now using the Bugzilla system to track all bug reports.
This web page gives detailed information on how to report bugs properly.
The GNU C Library is free software. See the file COPYING.LIB for copying
conditions, and LICENSES for notices about a few contributions that require
these additional notices to be distributed. License copyright years may be
listed using range notation, e.g., 1996-2015, indicating that every year in
the range, inclusive, is a copyrightable year that would otherwise be listed
individually.