This branch introduces a generic TEE framework in the kernel, to handle
trusted environemtns (security coprocessor or software implementations
such as OP-TEE/TrustZone). I'm sending it separately from the other
arm-soc driver changes to give it a little more visibility, once
the subsystem is merged, we will likely keep this in the arm₋soc
drivers branch or have the maintainers submit pull requests directly,
depending on the patch volume.
I have reviewed earlier versions in the past, and have reviewed
the latest version in person during Linaro Connect BUD17.
Here is my overall assessment of the subsystem:
* There is clearly demand for this, both for the generic
infrastructure and the specific OP-TEE implementation.
* The code has gone through a large number of reviews,
and the review comments have all been addressed, but
the reviews were not coming up with serious issues any more
and nobody volunteered to vouch for the quality.
* The user space ioctl interface is sufficient to work with the
OP-TEE driver, and it should in principle work with other
TEE implementations that follow the GlobalPlatform[1] standards,
but it might need to be extended in minor ways depending on
specific requirements of future TEE implementations
* The main downside of the API to me is how the user space
is tied to the TEE implementation in hardware or firmware,
but uses a generic way to communicate with it. This seems
to be an inherent problem with what it is trying to do,
and I could not come up with any better solution than what
is implemented here.
For a detailed history of the patch series, see
https://lkml.org/lkml/2017/3/10/1277
Conflicts: needs a fixup after the drm tree was merged, see
https://patchwork.kernel.org/patch/9691679/
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1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=VzpB
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Merge tag 'armsoc-tee' of git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/arm/arm-soc
Pull TEE driver infrastructure and OP-TEE drivers from Arnd Bergmann:
"This introduces a generic TEE framework in the kernel, to handle
trusted environemtns (security coprocessor or software implementations
such as OP-TEE/TrustZone). I'm sending it separately from the other
arm-soc driver changes to give it a little more visibility, once the
subsystem is merged, we will likely keep this in the arm₋soc drivers
branch or have the maintainers submit pull requests directly,
depending on the patch volume.
I have reviewed earlier versions in the past, and have reviewed the
latest version in person during Linaro Connect BUD17.
Here is my overall assessment of the subsystem:
- There is clearly demand for this, both for the generic
infrastructure and the specific OP-TEE implementation.
- The code has gone through a large number of reviews, and the review
comments have all been addressed, but the reviews were not coming
up with serious issues any more and nobody volunteered to vouch for
the quality.
- The user space ioctl interface is sufficient to work with the
OP-TEE driver, and it should in principle work with other TEE
implementations that follow the GlobalPlatform[1] standards, but it
might need to be extended in minor ways depending on specific
requirements of future TEE implementations
- The main downside of the API to me is how the user space is tied to
the TEE implementation in hardware or firmware, but uses a generic
way to communicate with it. This seems to be an inherent problem
with what it is trying to do, and I could not come up with any
better solution than what is implemented here.
For a detailed history of the patch series, see
https://lkml.org/lkml/2017/3/10/1277"
* tag 'armsoc-tee' of git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/arm/arm-soc:
arm64: dt: hikey: Add optee node
Documentation: tee subsystem and op-tee driver
tee: add OP-TEE driver
tee: generic TEE subsystem
dt/bindings: add bindings for optee
a2d9214c73